Resolution for Temporary Treasurer Gets Committee Fired Up
Prior to a 3-2 vote, township committee members square off over the township treasurer's position.
Vacant township treasurer and assistant treasurer positions proved to be a matter of heated debate at the final township committee meeting of 2012 on Friday.
After Committeeman Samuel Cianfarini explained the state of emergency the township faced, his candidate for the seat—Brenda Sprigman—was not welcomed with open arms by everyone. And while Cianfarini’s new candidate was voted in 3-2 along party lines, a bigger question remained for Democratic Committeewomen Denice DiCarlo and Donna Szymborski.
How did the township get into this bind?
What seemed like an otherwise short end-of-year meeting soon turned into a floor for much debate after Cianfarini asked the township committee to vote on a resolution to grant Sprigman temporary treasurer status. She will serve as the township continues to try to fill the vacant assistant treasurer position and begins a search to fill the newly vacant treasurer position, following Richard Giuliani’s decision to retire as of Jan. 1, 2013.
However, DiCarlo was very skeptical of Cianfarini’s candidate—stating that while she was very qualified, she had no municipal experience.
“I don’t think hiring someone without municipal experience gets us out of this bind,” said DiCarlo.
Questions about the job candidates
The treasurer and assistant treasurer oversee the township's finances.
DiCarlo explained that without the necessary experience, it may take Sprigman an entire month just to get familiarized with the day to day work, and instead suggested that the committee hold off a couple of weeks until the township could advertise for the position.
“We need a body in the office; we can’t go a couple of weeks,” said Deputy Mayor Sean Kilpatrick, who joined the meeting via phone.
However, DiCarlo pressed on asking why there was still an empty assistant treasurer seat in the township, when it should have been filled last summer.
Cianfarini said the township had only received five applicants for the assistant treasurer’s position in the summer and that three had dropped out. Of the two applicants that remained, one did not qualify for the job and the other was not deemed a viable candidate by Cianfarini. When Szymborski pressed Cianfarini on this matter, he explained that when looking into the candidate’s background, certain things did not line up—making the candidate untrustworthy in his eyes. Afterward, he refused to comment further on the matter—simply stating that he did not wish to “blackball” the former candidate.
Debate on Sprigman became more heated when DiCarlo asked Cianfarini why he believed Sprigman was more trustworthy than the former candidate from the summer. To this, Cianfarini responded that Sprigman was a member of the Republican Party—which is how he met her.
“She’s from the Republican Party; well, that makes sense,” said DiCarlo.
A party official
According to the West Deptford Republican Party website, Sprigman is listed as the vice chair of the West Deptford Republican Party.
However, as of later Friday evening, Republican Party Chair Denny Forte released a statement confirming that Sprigman had turned in her resignation as vice chair of the GOP.
DiCarlo expounded on her frustrations by blaming Cianfarini for the township's lack of an assistant treasurer. Cianfarini then explained that the job of hiring an assistant treasurer falls on the township administrator, Eric Campo. Campo said he would not hire someone without the support of the committee, after first going to the subcommittee—yet, he explained he was behind the former candidate.
“I thought our candidate was a viable candidate,” said Campo.
Mayor Raymond Chintall also added that the former candidate was asking for a salary upward of $100,000 for the assistant treasurer’s position, and that he was not inclined to vote for a candidate simply because they were the only one.
“I’m not giving someone an extra $30,000 just because they’re the last man standing,” said Chintall in defense of his decision.
Szymborski pointed out that the former candidate asked for the same salary Sprigman currently seeks.
After more discussion and a heated outburst from Cianfarini, when Szymborski cut into his floor time, the committee agreed that Sprigman would only be paid hourly with the workweek not to exceed 35 hours. After striking his original resolution, Cianfarini restated the resolution to include the amendments. Cianfarini, Chintall and Kilpatrick voted in favor of the appointment, while DiCarlo and Szymborski voted against it.
Sprigman will begin her appointment on Dec. 31.
sandie
11:07 am on Saturday, December 29, 2012
Well, well. Looks like 2013 is going to be just more of the same nonsense. I have to say though, being a member of a political party should not be the reason anyone gets vetted for a public office, especially treasurer. It would appear the hidden agenda behind not approving a prior candidate has just been exposed. Let the games begin.
government_watchdog
11:07 am on Saturday, December 29, 2012
This constant backbiting within the Committee is counterproductive and does a disservice to the taxpaying residents.
A township with the employee base of West Deptford's does not need a highly paid Treasurer. It just needs a good bookkeeper. Here are figures from similar job positions of a county government agency with over 600 employees. The Fiscal Officer (Treasurer) with over 39 years on the job receives a salary $115K. The Accountant (Asst Treasurer) with 35 years receives a salary of $76K. The Bookkeeper, who actually does the work, with over 40 years receives a salary of $63K. West Deptford's finance department is "Top Heavy".
Jester Holmes
11:07 am on Saturday, December 29, 2012
How can you hire a treasurer with no municipal experience whatsoever and is completely unqualified for the postiion? her only qualification is being a member of the republican party.
Tom Stanton
1:26 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
It sounds as you are doing the typical Liberal dance, the twist. Although Mrs. DiCarlo questioned Ms. Sprigman's municipality experience, she also stated that she is very qualified.
Tom Stanton
11:07 am on Saturday, December 29, 2012
IF it happened as Patch has portrayed the scenario in the article, just being a member of the Republican party does not make you a trustworthy candidate. Just the same, not having municipal experience does not make you unqualified to fill a needed position.
I believe the more pressing question here is the reason for the urgency to fill the position. If the position for assistant treasurer was open since the summer, why have we waited so long to fill it? (Lack of money?) (An oversight?) Why was there only 5 applicants to apply for a good job in this poor job market? Mrs. DiCarlo wanted to advertise for the position. Was this position not advertised? If not, how did we get 5 applicants?
Just some simple questions. If anyone has any legit answers, it will be appreciated.
Madeline Fucci
11:07 am on Saturday, December 29, 2012
Unlike Denice DiCarlo and Rich Giulliani, Brenda Sprigman is a CPA and a highly qualified individual who would serve the township well. She has had 25 years of private sector experience and worked for major corporations such as RCA, DuPont, Colgate Palmolive and a financial investment firm. While she may not have municipal finance experience as stated by DiCarlo, this would be a "no brainer" for such an intelligent and experienced individual as Brenda Sprigman. When are the good people of West Deptford going to wake up and stop electing political hacks and obstructionists such as DiCarlo and Szymborski who helped create the financial mess we are now faced with and wanting to continue with the same people and policies that are the problem not the solution. Brenda Sprigman is not only a highly qualified and experienced individual she is also very honorable woman and a person of great integrity. Her first priority will always be what is in the best interest of the town and we are lucky to have her willing to step up to the plate and serve the community.
Clinton Potts
12:44 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
I don't think anyone knows who was slated for this position.It was the freeholder R Damminger's brother that was in line for the position,but he did not have the credentials to fill the position,however Dicarlo and her bosom buddy Donna wanted him as per instructions from no other than G (i'll do anything to fill my pockets ) White.They got shot down so now it's starting to sway the other way before it was all dems and you democRATS just don't like it.this year will be the downfall of a lot of dems that hold office because you leader THE PREZ. will fall flat on his face and we will be in the biggest recession since 1931.
Papa Bear
1:26 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
Springman seems qualified in every respect. The fact that she has no municipal experience is a plus. As a CPA and a citizen she is well aware of what a municipality should do and would not be tainted by past practices. Past practices is what got us into the mess were in. More experienced, common sense citizens are needed in government and less politcians.
Madeline Fucci
9:18 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
By holding up the appointment of Brenda Sprigman for a few weeks or a month, it looks like a deliberate strategy to shut down the Finance Department. This would hold up and delay the cutting of pay checks to the employees and make the Republicans look incompetent. Once again Denice and Donna playing partisan politics and obeying their puppet master Gerry White. Also, why wouldn't Giulianni offer to assist Brenda during the transition period. This is the customary thing to do among professional people but I suppose I am asking too much knowing the toxic environment in this town since the Dems lost control. Are they afraid what might be uncovered by a qualified person in the position of Assistant Treasurer? Once again, not what is in the best interest of the community but doing whatever is necessary to serve their political interests.
William Libby
9:18 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
Look at all the repugnican clowns trying to justify the unjustifiable! Fucci, Stanton, Umba and Forte! At least you fully exposed yourselves for all to see. This is as bad as when Ray and Sam tried to profit off of a disabled boy and the same bunch of you tried to justify that as well. Or how about Sam and his high morality accepting donations from a strip club for needy families because he botched the holiday toy drive. I seem to remember a few of the same folks trying to justify how well the toy drive went this year. Last year there were 80 or 90 families that needed support. This year, in their infinite wisdom, they capped the families at 20, stopped acceptIng monetary donations, made the families come to the community center to get their turkeys instead of delivering them so the families didn't have to let everyone know they were in need of assistance. It was an embarrassment in every sense of the word and to top it all off they couldn't even finish the job without the help of Club Champagne. Good job boys. This should make for some good responses justifying all of this! I'd like to hear the lies and excuses.
Robert Libby
11:23 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
we heard the lies and excuses for 25 years time for new lies and excuses.don't like it do my brother.you must have gone through a lot of crying towels in the past year.
what I don't understand if you don't like what's goin on why don't you move.
or run next election then you can have all the say you want.
Tom Stanton
11:23 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
You would have made Chubby Checker proud. To twist my comment into a support for an employee's hiring based on the reported (unquoted) basis of trustworthy as being part of the Republican party is ludicrous.
With the disdain of a dysfunctional township government picture that you like to spew, you must have been a fire breathing dragon with the previous administrations. Either that, or a typical Liberal, full of hot air.
William Libby
9:45 pm on Sunday, December 30, 2012
Robert, my brother from another mother. Haven't heard from you in while. Still the black sheep of the family I see. As for Mr. Stanton, nothing to say of any substance as expected. Of course not much can be said which was also expected.
Bill Chintall
9:18 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
She is not a CPA, her license in inactive. Who is next in line to get hired, Ken & Janet Vogt, Jack Magee, Brandon Umba? The only job qualificaitons you need to be hired in WD now is to be a member of the republican party executive committee. First Michelle Taint Hack and now Sprigman. Sam and Ray are the biggest hypocrites on planet earth.
bvhj
Robert Libby
11:23 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
they certainly aren't going to hire a democrat idiot.just like the previous admin they only hired within their party.such an imbecile.
Robin Stanton
4:29 pm on Sunday, December 30, 2012
Wait...I missed the update on the rule change. A CPA was simply defined as passing a test during the campaign, but is now being defined as having an active license?
Madeline Fucci
9:50 pm on Saturday, December 29, 2012
Wow! Two Republicans on the township payroll. How many Democrats are employed by the township and the county? Comments like those of Libby are a joke. He went from Sprigman to turkeys to Club Champagne. Anything else for good measure? Maybe Damminger's brother should have been appointed. I'm sure that would have made the Democrats and Libby happy.
William Libby
9:45 pm on Sunday, December 30, 2012
The turkeys and club champagne are linked. You are not even aware of what is going on. Suggest you take a Centrum Silver and educate yourself on the issues.
Walter Frockmorton
11:23 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
Maybe the next person to fill this position can have a look around and find the ledger that has been missing since 2007.
R Kramer
11:23 am on Sunday, December 30, 2012
I wonder how long it will be before someone on here brings a libel and defamation of character lawsuit against the patch for the constant comments and derogatory remarks to other people on here.
It's like they thrive on this type of commentary.
rumor has it thet Mr. Klotz is in the process of legal advice for the constant bashing he recieves on here.
Happy New Year!
Wayne Klotz
4:29 pm on Sunday, December 30, 2012
Thanks for the advice, mr.Kramer, but I do take this bashing like a man. And I do use my real name when I have to say anything on patch! The next meeting I will be there to ask a few questions!!!
Occupant
8:59 am on Monday, December 31, 2012
Try to stay awake at the next meeting Waynemeister....
Madeline Fucci
8:53 pm on Sunday, December 30, 2012
You can always expect the people who have difficulty discussing an issue from an alternative point of view to reduce themselves to name calling and personal attacks on this site. I suppose it's due to their frustration or lack of intelligence.
Madeline Fucci
8:59 am on Monday, December 31, 2012
The entire article being discussed was about the appointment of an Assistant Treasurer not the turkey drive and Club Champagne . Why not stay on point and discuss the matter at hand. However, you managed to prove my point by your comment. Thank you. I suppose the shoe did fit because you wore it beautifully.