.

OPMA Lawsuit Against Republicans Goes to Court Friday

Arguments over whether closed-door meetings prior to January's reorganization meeting violated state law will be heard in court.

Five months after a judge ruled West Deptford’s entire township committee violated the Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA) in failing to disclose the terms of the initial version of the Eagle Point settlement with Sunoco, the committee’s three Republicans will be back in court Friday to defend themselves against another alleged OPMA violation.

The suit, filed by Gary Kuehnapfel, who was also the plaintiff in the Sunoco settlement suit, targets the majority of the committee—Mayor Ray Chintall, Deputy Mayor Sean Kilpatrick and committeeman Sam Cianfarini—for alleged closed-door dealings ahead of the township government’s reorganization in January, where the Republicans allegedly interviewed prospective township professionals and decided on a new insurance broker—secret meetings that the suit claims violated state law.

But the Republicans, who declined to comment on the suit ahead of the judge’s decision, indicate in their legal response they had no choice but to consider some of the professional appointments ahead of the reorganization meeting, due to what they claim was a “looming disaster” with the township’s insurance.

The Traveler’s letter

The Dec. 23, 2011, letter to what was then the township’s insurance carrier—a letter put out on official township letterhead and signed by all three Republicans—referenced various policy numbers and advised the insurance company there would be a switch in brokers, from Democrat-appointed Martin Company to Anderson Jackson Metts, effective the day Chintall and Cianfarini were to be sworn in at the beginning of 2012, which would take place about two weeks after the date of the letter.

According to township solicitor Anthony Ogozalek’s legal brief in response to the lawsuit, the letter didn’t come out of a closed-door meeting, but was drafted after the Republicans claim they found out the township’s insurance broker at the time, the Martin Company, was refusing to issue copies of the township’s 2011 policy, as they had requested, and was also refusing to provide 2012 insurance cards for township-owned vehicles.

The letter, Ogozalek wrote, was a measure to keep Traveler's abreast of the situation and avoid any potential problems with continuing the township's insurance coverage.

But trying to claim there was a crisis, when local governments change control without issue on a regular basis, weakens that argument, West Deptford Democratic Party chair Gerald White said.

“There’s no need to break the law to ensure the coverage is bound over,” he said.

The language in the December letter to Traveler’s—a statement of intent to switch brokers—is what Kuehnapfel’s Democratically connected attorney, John Trimble Jr., cited as evidence a final call had been made behind closed doors.

“The defendants may not have formally voted or appointed, but an official decision was made prior to January 5, 2012,” he wrote in his response to Ogozalek’s brief.

The Republicans’ failure to file a copy of the letter to Traveler's, which was revealed in an Open Public Records Act (OPRA) filing was also included as part of the suit, with Trimble arguing if nothing else, the official signature from Kilpatrick made it a public document and subject to OPRA.

Political caucus

A subsequent Dec. 28 meeting that involved interviews of candidates for township engineers, including Ed Steck, who gave a statement when the suit was initially filed in June, should have been exempt under OPMA, Ogozalek wrote.

That meeting—attended by Ogozalek, the three Republicans and Brandon Umba, who’s referenced as a political adviser, though Chintall said earlier Umba wasn’t serving in a formal capacity—wasn’t covered under OPMA, Ogozalek wrote, because Chintall and Cianfarini had yet to be sworn in as members of West Deptford’s township committee, and thus didn’t have the power to take any official action prior to the township’s reorganization meeting in January and had, in fact, been barred from taking part in closed sessions at several township committee meetings near the end of 2011.

“The key word in the statute is ‘empowered,’” Ogozalek wrote.

He then went on to argue the meeting should be considered under OPMA’s exception for political caucuses, writing the meetings were “clearly political in nature.”

“The interviews held on December 28th were for the purpose of determining how the professional appointments made on January 5, 2012, would politically impact the Republican Party of West Deptford,” Ogozalek argued in the brief.

That sentiment was echoed in both Chintall and Cianfarini’s nearly identical certifications included with Ogozalek’s brief—a sentiment White ripped.

“In sworn legal statements from Republican West Deptford township committee members, they admitted to being worried about the impact of new professional appointments on the Republican Party of West Deptford,” he said. “Not the town, not the residents, not the taxpayers, but their own political party.”

In his response, Trimble argued to be considered political caucuses, things have to be done carefully to avoid making final decisions, focusing only on politics.

“The defendants are attempting to use the statute as a shield and blatantly disregard the entire basis and intent behind the Open Public Meetings Act,” he wrote.

The lawsuit

Kuehnapfel’s second suit of the year comes after his win against the committee in the Sunoco settlement, the initial version of which was voided by the court after Superior Court Judge Eugene McCaffrey Jr. ruled the committee did, in fact, violate OPMA by failing to disclose the settlement’s terms.

As a part-time employee at Gloucester County College, state records show Kuehnapfel—who is also listed as running a computer services company—makes $12,252 per year, but he has still managed to arrange for Trimble’s services and gotten the cooperation of Democratically appointed professionals, despite Democratic Party officials disavowing any connection with him.

While he issued a handful of statements via his attorney in the Sunoco suit, Kuehnapfel has stayed in the background otherwise, not appearing at the court action that saw the Sunoco settlement overturned and not issuing any statements with the current OPMA suit.

Arguments in the suit are scheduled for Friday afternoon in front of McCaffrey.

Concerned and worried citizen September 20, 2012 at 01:15 PM
Just when we get our ship righted another political torpedo. We begin to see some light at the end of the tunnel, maybe have some hope our township and residents will gain some value back and the "other" side volleys. When we all realize we had 20 plus years of mis-management, needed some proactive straightforward leadership (BIPARTISAN) and stop spending on "our feelings got hurt" lawsuits?
Madeline Fucci September 20, 2012 at 01:43 PM
Here it is close to election time and the Democrat machine trots out their useful dupes to instigate frivolous lawsuits to divert attention from the fraud and corruption that the new administration has uncovered. The Democrats are ignoring the fact that Mayor Cintall and company resolved expensive and extensive litigation that had been going on for 22 years and saved the township over $300,000 in insurance premiums that was going to their political cronies plus increased our coverage and all we get is a smokescreen to cover their nefarious practices. If Ray Cintall and Sam Cianfarini had not won the election, it would have been business as usual, sustained and increasing debt running the town further into the ground. Wake up residents of West Deptford. We are making progress. Even after the Sunoco settlement, we maintained an A- bond rating.
Harry lucas September 20, 2012 at 01:55 PM
Madeline did you take your pills this morning Sam ,Ray did nothing for Wd but cost the taxpayers more $$$$$ there time is up we need a real leader in charge Denise decarlo in nov.
Madeline Fucci September 20, 2012 at 02:00 PM
Harry: Whats in your Koolade?
Concerned and worried citizen September 20, 2012 at 02:09 PM
Actually HARRY. it's Denice. Kind of spelled funny just like funny she has done anything or proven anything. HARRY another head in the sand guy.
Lauren Burgoon September 20, 2012 at 02:16 PM
Readers, please stay on topic here. No need to attack each other, especially if you would never say these things to each other in person.
W.D.78 September 20, 2012 at 02:30 PM
Maybe we as residents should start hitting all the dishonest Dems with bogus law suits from years past.Maybe we should expose the names of these thieves who have gotten away with all these dirty deeds for years. Like the names of the persons who all of the checks in round numbers were actually made out to or the name of the water and sewer employee who didn't pay a water bill for 10 years or the names of the employees that were getting there insurance benefits payed for out of the riverwinds development money.Maybe then the Dems will stop trying to impeed our progress by the New commitee people who are doing what needs to be done for us the residents of W.D.
Bill Bondar September 20, 2012 at 02:40 PM
A point I'd like to make here is the fact that I know these guys, Sam and Ray. They in my opinion have nothing but the best for WD in mind. There are Republicans, Democrats and Independents in this town so we are all in this together. Unfortunately there is a faction of the Democratic party that have had unclean hands when it comes to township business. We tried it their way for 20+ years, lets give the new committee people a chance to do their thing. Please stop all the bickering. There are only a hand full of people who use this forum, not the entire town, so most people don't know or don't care what goes on in township government. Its turning into a bitch session instead of constructive criticism here and it's getting old, like me.
redneckwillie3 September 20, 2012 at 03:23 PM
well said bill. it's the same residents that say the same thing over and over,it's getting old. we all have opinions and we're entitled to them,however it was last year that dicarlo and kintzing we're attacking ray & sam and what happened people are tired of the rhetoric. let's not forget people vote for who they think is going to do a good job,all political connections in this town will vote for the right person. go to the meeting tonight and see what's being uncovered it will shock a lot of people especially the dems.
Wayne Klotz September 20, 2012 at 07:15 PM
you are right, redneckwillie3 but the republicans threw the first stone!
R Nichols September 20, 2012 at 07:32 PM
I'm all for intelligent debate & discussions of OPINION. (in caps for emphasis) but i would expect more from middle school students in respect to some of the insults & bickering that goes in these comments sections. You're embarrassing yourselves people.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something